Q: I have a 4 month old freshwater, 20 gal. aquarium containing one Red Wag Platy, one Mickey Mouse Platy, two Red-Eye Tetras, two Black Skirt Tetras, four Striped Danios, two Harlequin Rasboras, two Endler's Livebearers and one algae eater. All have healthy appetites, water tests just fine, 25% water changes are performed monthly (altho' this usually kills at least one fish). My problem is that I enjoy the Platys because they add color to the tank. However, each time I try to add a new fish, it dies. All current tank residents are fine, no signs of illness, but new Platy or Sword arrivals die within a week. What's going on?

A: It sounds like a pH problem, what is the pH of your tank, your tap water and the LFS water? are they close. The current inhabitants of you tank could have adapted to a low/high ph over the time period, but any new ones would be "shocked" when added. Also the fact of at least one fish dying during a water change also leads me to believe this. Are you also using a chlorine remover when you make changes?.

Main index Navigation Badmans Tropical Fish! Fishkeeping ABCs Favorite Fish Fish Families Detailed Information In Depth Definitions Natures Way The Equipment Whats That Mean? Want More Just For Fun Guestbook Site Search, What's New